I think part of the problem is what any person in the media has issues with. They get "known" for something and immediately start to take it to extreme levels.

The FFXIII reviewer - sarcastic son of a bitch who's angry at everything
The Metro non reviewer - games as art and indie gamer guy

It's great to have a particular characterization for people to relate to. This is another reason why Destructoid caught my attention. Their staff seemed unique and not at all faceless. They had loads of character and it felt more honest when they gave their opinions. However, it just seems they're getting too carried away with it at times.